American Council on Science and Health American Council on Science and Health
About
ACSH
¥ Contact
ACSH
¥ Support
ACSH
¥ My
ACSH
¥ Advanced
Search
 
ACSH.org   Home   . .   Health Issues   . .   News Center   . .   Publications   . .   Events   . .   FactsAndFears   .  

Health Facts And Fears

Archives >

Printer Format icon Printer Format
E-mail Information icon E-mail Information
July 20, 2010

Dispatch: Inaccurate Dietary Guidelines

It seems that ACSH staffers may have discovered that the U.S. Department of Agriculture and the FDA, which revise dietary guidelines for Americans every five years, are even more reluctant to admit to a mistake than your average guy. In today’s LA Times, an op-ed written by City Journal columnist Steven Malanga observes that there’s increasing scientific evidence that past and current federal dietary recommendations are often wrong. For instance, in the March issue of the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, researchers analyzed the daily food intake of 350,000 people and found no link between the amount of saturated fat ingested and the risk of heart disease, even though Americans have been told since 1980 to supplant saturated fats with carbohydrates.

“The diet-to-heart connection just isn’t holding up. By recommending an increase in carbohydrates over fat, the government has actually contributed to the obesity epidemic,” points out ACSH’s Dr. Elizabeth Whelan.

In its new recommendations, the FDA advises Americans to reduce daily sodium intake to a maximum of 1,500 milligrams. “This guideline is not consistent with good health for the majority of Americans, not to mention impossible to comply with, and is likely to do more harm than good,” says ACSH's Dr. Gilbert Ross.

“In the 1970s, the dogma was not to eat more than one visible egg per day, but now we know eggs are very nutritious and one of the least dangerous foods one can eat. The FDA is just wrong, and their recommendations reflect popular wisdom more than science,” says Dr. Whelan. “They’re just not willing to make modifications even when science shows the truth.”

Visitor Responses

hart oldenburg (July 21, 2010)

Misguiding Americans started with the pyramid food guide, causing,carbohydritis, obesity.
To make it as blunt as I can; making people eat the very same food, farmers feed their livestock to fatten it.

I am the very recent discoverer of the cause of obesity.It reveals the past wrongs. hartsmartliving.com


Dispatch!
Want to receive ACSH's daily email blast on the latest public health news and junk science scares?
(Here's a sample)
Enter your email below. (It will be kept strictly confidential — will not be sold).
Subscribe to ACSH.org RSS  FactsAndFears posts on YOUR site
Search Archives Icon for Search
Search

Icon for Browse Archives Browse Archives

Sign In Icon for Sign In

Username:

Password:

Sign In Now >>

Forget your password?

Register

Why register with ACSH?
You'll be able to:
¥ Post comments to articles
¥ Subscribe to e-bulletin
¥ Receive immediate or scheduled updates


Register Now >>


AMERICAN COUNCIL ON SCIENCE AND HEALTH  |  1995 BROADWAY, 2ND FLOOR, NEW YORK, NY 10023-5860
TELEPHONE: (212) 362-7044  |  FAX: (212) 362-4919  |  E-MAIL: GEN. ORGANIZATION MAILBOX: acsh (at) acsh.org; IND. STAFFER: [last name or last name followed by first initial]@acsh.org 

Copyright © 1997-2004 American Council on Science and Health  |  Privacy Policy  |  All Rights Reserved
.

Founded in 1978, ACSH is a consumer advocacy organization directed and advised by over 350 physicians, scientists and policy advisors. ACSH promotes the use of sound, peer-reviewed science in the formation of a full  spectrum of  public health policies, including those related to food, pharmaceuticals, environmental chemicals, lifestyle factors, consumer products and terrorism preparedness and response.